Home > New York > Shelter Island

Search:

Refine Your Search Criteria:

Local Guide

Shelter Island Real Estate -- 25 Listings

Market Summary

Avg. Listing Price
$1,778,756

25 Homes for sale
7 Foreclosures

Sort by

12 Petticoat Ln

$479,000
Shelter Island, NY 11964
MLS# 2456903
3 Beds / 2 Baths

N/A sq. ft / yr built: N/A
More Info / Photos

12 Petticoat Ln

$479,000
Shelter Island, NY 11964
MLS# 2456903
3 Beds / 2 Baths

1,392 sq. ft / yr built: 1963
More Info / Photos

2 Valley Rd

$519,000
Shelter Island, NY 11964
MLS# 8034074
3 Beds / 2 Baths

1,950 sq. ft / yr built: 1977
More Info / Photos

18 Manhanset Rd

$525,000
Shelter Island, NY 11964
MLS# 2451043
3 Beds / 3 Baths

1,706 sq. ft / yr built: 1978
More Info / Photos

82 Smith St

$549,000
Shelter Island, NY 11964
MLS# 2392491
1 Beds / 1 Baths

660 sq. ft / yr built: 1953
More Info / Photos

10 Fox Hollow Run

$595,000
Shelter Island, NY 11964
MLS# 2434739
3 Beds / 2 Baths

1,800 sq. ft / yr built: 1989
More Info / Photos

17 Congdon Rd

$674,900
Shelter Island, NY 11964
MLS# 2168933
2 Beds / 2 Baths

1,200 sq. ft / yr built: 1972
More Info / Photos

3 Fox Hollow Run

$675,000
Shelter Island, NY 11964
MLS# 2441615
4 Beds / 3 Baths

2,640 sq. ft / yr built: 2003
More Info / Photos

4 Glynn Dr

$699,000
Shelter Island, NY 11964
MLS# 2451032
4 Beds / 3 Baths

2,633 sq. ft / yr built: 2000
More Info / Photos

2 Margarets Dr

$725,000
Shelter Island, NY 11964
MLS# 2443069
4 Beds / 3 Baths

2,866 sq. ft / yr built: 1987
More Info / Photos

29 Hilo Dr

$735,000
Shelter Island, NY 11964
MLS# 2350069
5 Beds / 3 Baths

1,969 sq. ft / yr built: 1966
More Info / Photos

29 Hilo Dr

$735,000
Shelter Island, NY 11964
MLS# 2350069
5 Beds / 2 Baths

1,969 sq. ft / yr built: 1966
More Info / Photos

10 N. Midway Rd

$749,000
Shelter Island, NY 11964
MLS# 2385598
2 Beds / 1 Baths

976 sq. ft / yr built: 1955
More Info / Photos

19 Shelterlands Path

$850,000
Shelter Island, NY 11964
MLS# 2452084
3 Beds / 3 Baths

2,096 sq. ft / yr built: 1988
More Info / Photos

13 Locust Woods Dr

$925,000
Shelter Island, NY 11964
MLS# 2374398
6 Beds / 4 Baths

4,200 sq. ft / yr built: 2000
More Info / Photos

13 Locust Woods Dr

$925,000
Shelter Island, NY 11964
MLS# 2374398
6 Beds / 5 Baths

4,200 sq. ft / yr built: 2000
More Info / Photos

18 Ferry Rd

$950,000
Shelter Island, NY 11964
MLS# 2461719
3 Beds / 3 Baths

N/A sq. ft / yr built: 2001
More Info / Photos

16 Lakeview Dr

$1,350,000
Shelter Island, NY 11964
MLS# 2385990
3 Beds / 3 Baths

3,803 sq. ft / yr built: 1998
More Info / Photos

16 Lakeview Dr

$1,350,000
Shelter Island, NY 11964
MLS# 2385990
3 Beds / 3 Baths

3,803 sq. ft / yr built: 1998
More Info / Photos

20 S Midway Rd

$1,395,000
Shelter Island, NY 11964
MLS# 2227991
5 Beds / 2 Baths

1,296 sq. ft / yr built: 1964
More Info / Photos

16 Margarets Dr

$1,395,000
Shelter Island, NY 11964
MLS# 2365131
4 Beds / 3 Baths

1,656 sq. ft / yr built: 1979
More Info / Photos

8 Deer Park Ln

$1,495,000
Shelter Island, NY 11964
MLS# 2439732
3 Beds / 3 Baths

N/A sq. ft / yr built: 2001
More Info / Photos

48 + 43 Winthrop Rd

$2,295,000
Shelter Island, NY 11964
MLS# 2427785
5 Beds / 4 Baths

3,472 sq. ft / yr built: 1956
More Info / Photos

22 Merkel Ln

$4,500,000
Shelter Island, NY 11964
MLS# 2307680
4 Beds / 6 Baths

6,400 sq. ft / yr built: 1965
More Info / Photos

64 Burns Rd

$18,900,000
Shelter Island, NY 11964
MLS# 2422791
12 Beds / 12 Baths

12,000 sq. ft / yr built: 1900
More Info / Photos

Email Alerts

Receive daily or weekly alerts for your search criteria.

Please Login to sign up for email alerts.

Get the latest MLS listings in a RSS feed

Schools Near Shelter Island, NY

Schools	Distance	# Students	Grades
Shelter Island School	2.94 miles	262	K-12
Stella Maris Regional School	3.90 miles	201	PK, K-8
Sag Harbor Elementary School	4.08 miles	421	K-5
Pierson Middle/high School	4.25 miles	514	6-12
Greenport Elementary School	5.84 miles	275	K-6
Greenport High School	5.84 miles	330	7-12
Oysterponds Elementary School	6.18 miles	100	K-6
Ross School	7.26 miles	135	PK, K-4
The Hayground School	7.92 miles	57	PK, K-8
Child Development Center Of The Hamptons Charter S	8.07 miles	61	K-5
Bridgehampton School	8.09 miles	159	PK, K-12
East Hampton High School	8.94 miles	948	9-12
Wainscott School	8.96 miles	21	K-3
Southold Elementary School	9.23 miles	437	K-6
Southold Junior-senior High School	9.23 miles	489	7-12
Schools provided by See more information on Shelter Island schools from Education.com